Both stream games to you over the internet 'Netflix for games' is the best analogy, if not perfectbut Stadia users have to buy Stadia versions of the games they want to stream, whereas GeForce Now streams games you already own on Steam or other platforms—at least when publishers allow it to. Nvidia has run into some issues in that department.
After the issues around game ownership, the biggest concern with game streaming technology is input latency. If you're running a game on your own hardware, the amount of time it takes for a mouse click to do something on your screen depends on your PC alone. But with Stadia and GeForce now, your input is sent to a server and the result is sent back to you as a video stream, which adds many variables to the process.
Running a game locally will nearly always give you lower input latency. The exception is when you're trying to run something that's way out of your hardware's league. If you're running a game at 5 fps locally, you're only seeing a new frame once every ms vs.
Otherwise, we're expecting local rendering to provide the lowest input latency, and judging these streaming services based on how close they come to matching that local experience. In my testing, GeForce Now beats Stadia when it comes to input latency.
GeForce Now beats Stadia in our input latency testing
The quality of both services will be heavily dependent on your particular network situation, and so your results may vary for one reason or another—you aren't in the same physical location as me, you have a different ISP, and so on—but my testing does show that Google's infrastructure doesn't necessarily offer the best results.
The screens were filmed at fps, and latency was measured by counting the frames between a button press and the action on screen to get the latency in milliseconds. I used the same mouse on both the desktop and laptop.
I left the bitrate setting in GeForce Now to 'auto,' since Stadia doesn't offer the same control. I then limited my bandwidth to 5Mbps to see how each game and platform performed under the most extreme conditions. I limited the fps on all games to When you customize your settings in the GeForce Now launcher, the maximum framerate is 60 fps. Google Stadia limits framerate to 60 on PC automatically. Using third-party software called Nvidia Inspector, I capped the framerate on Metro Exodus and Destiny 2 to 60 fps when running them locally.
The external framerate limiter applied to locally rendered games adds to input latency, and it may add more or less than the limiters controlling the GeForce Now and Stadia versions. We can't control every variable perfectly, and opted to keep framerates identical above all else. Don't consider the local input latency results to be the best possible results under ideal conditions—they aren't, but the difference between the local and streaming latency results is consistent.
All tests were performed on ultra at p, aside from running the games locally on my laptop which was tested on low graphics to keep performance up. Additionally, since my laptop and Google Stadia don't have an option for ray tracing, all tests were performed with ray tracing off.
There is a separate section for a comparison with and without ray tracing, where my desktop with an RTX Ti and GeForce Now are compared. Note: The videos in this article can help give you a sense of the pixelation and rubberbanding that can occur with streaming services at low bandwidth, but of course, the videos themselves have been compressed and are being streamed to you, so everything including the local gameplay is going to look a bit worse than it actually did.
As you can see in the table below, GeForce Now registered between 40msms less input latency than Stadia when playing Metro Exodus, depending on the bandwidth. In Destiny 2, GeForce Now's latency saw a minimal increase when going from high bandwidth to low bandwidth, whereas Stadia's latency tanked. However, I encountered rubberbanding several times on Stadia, even with high bandwidth.
You can see an example of that at in the video, when the camera involuntarily jerks to the side.
It was so bad at times that it felt like the game was possessed, and restarting it had no effect. Gameplay was still smooth, and I didn't encounter any lag or rubberbanding, though the pixelation definitely made it hard to see at times. GeForce Now never disconnected me from the game. However, the lag was so bad on Stadia that if I didn't disconnect, I always died before reaching a safe spot. If you skip ahead in the video to the Destiny 2 gameplay, you'll see the same results.
Rubberbanding timestampalthough not as bad as in Metro Exodus and massive lag on Stadia, and massive pixelation in GeForce Now. Input latency results are more of the same on a laptop via a 5Ghz wireless connection.
Latency is of course lowest when running a game locally, while GeForce Now comes in second and Google Stadia in third. Stadia has 8ms less latency than GeForce Now in that case, but it's such a small difference that any random hiccup in traffic could account for it.Joinsubscribers and get a daily digest of news, geek trivia, and our feature articles. That allowed you to keep the number of frames in the render queue down. This works with all GPUs.
However, it only works with DirectX 9 and DirectX 11 games. Warning : This will potentially reduce your FPS. Select how you want to enable Ultra-Low Latency Mode. Remember, as we pointed out above, this option can actually hurt performance in many situations! We recommend enabling it only for specific games and testing your settings to see how well it actually works. Comments 0. The Best Tech Newsletter Anywhere.
Joinsubscribers and get a daily digest of news, comics, trivia, reviews, and more. Windows Mac iPhone Android. Smarthome Office Security Linux. The Best Tech Newsletter Anywhere Joinsubscribers and get a daily digest of news, geek trivia, and our feature articles. Skip to content. How-To Geek is where you turn when you want experts to explain technology.
Since we launched inour articles have been read more than 1 billion times. Want to know more?Despite a janky interface and some atrocious catalogue holes, GeForce Now is a genuinely exciting service. But on two less-than-stellar connections, the service was barely operational. Thankfully, you can make your own mind up on that — you can try GeForce Now for free before deciding to subscribe.
Nvidia GeForce Now Review. Nvidia hops in the stream. Nvidia GeForce Now is as exciting as it is poorly marketed. In that time, Google launched its Stadia service and Microsoft xCloud opened its own beta. But GeForce Now might not need mindshare to win out over its competitors. Instead, GeForce Now connects to your existing digital game libraries to verify if you own the games you want to play.
But it also means only select games are supported. When you find a game you want to play, you click a button to add it to your library.
GeForce then asks you to confirm that you own the game. Then a new dialogue box appears, establishing your connection to the GeForce servers.
GeForce opens what looks like a virtualized desktop, complete with a virtualized window of Steam, Epic Games Store or whatever client you own the game at. In this case, I finally finished authenticating everything and had to wait about 5 minutes for an available rig to play Destiny 2.
Finally, after what seemed like an eternity, I was able to start a game. When I opened certain games, the controller inputs stopped working altogether despite the games technically providing gamepad support.
For example, if you select The Witcher 3 in GeForce Now and launch into the virtualized Steam page, but then decide you want to play Cuphead instead, you have to fully exit out of the virtual machine and re-launch Cuphead from GeForce Now. From a user experience standpoint, things could definitely be streamlined. Heck, I had a great experience in one room of my house, and a slipshod experience in another.
Nvidia recommends a minimum of 15 mbps for 60fps at p or 30 mbps for p, and suggests connecting via Ethernet for the best experience. In testing, sometimes you need a fair bit more than that. When I checked, I was rocking Under those conditions, the quality of my experience depended just as much on my internet speeds as which game I was playing. Less resource-intensive games, like Cuphead, played perfectly. Despite the game requiring lightning-fast reflexes, I was able to make my way easily through several boss fights.
But when I tried more graphically intensive games, like Destiny 2, the game stuttered, I felt noticeable latency, and the visuals descended into a smudgy, cubist hellscape.What do you do with a thick stack of high-end GPUs and expertise in data center hardware? I was surprised when I first learned of GeForce Now in early On further thought, however, it makes perfect sense. Nvidia dominated consumer graphics over the last decade, but also grew its footprint in data centers.
It only sells the service. You bring your own collection from other digital storefronts. Nvidia boasts compatibility with hundreds of titles across a variety of storefronts, including Steam, The Epic Store, and Ubisoft Activision-Blizzard pulled its games soon after launch, as has Bethesda, unfortunately. That means game ownership and the GeForce Now service are entirely separate. You can purchase a Steam game with the intent to play on GeForce Now, but the two are never linked or dependent on each other.
If you unsubscribe, you still own the game on Steam and can play the game on any PC. Personally, I stepped into GeForce Now with over 50 compatible games.
At time of this writing, eight of the ten most played titles on Steam are playable on GeForce Now. Like Stadia, Shadow, and most cloud gaming services, GeForce Now relies on a local application to stream games to your device. As an iPhone fan, this is a problem. I hope Nvidia and Apple can mend their divide and bring an app to iOS soon. Joining GeForce Now could be easier.
The GeForce Now client, once installed, proves quick. No system stumbled for even a moment. Navigating the PC client, like the website, could be easier. Instead, you must search for titles one-by-one. I think some users will find that confusing. Launching a game opens a bandwidth test, which, if all goes well, is soon followed by the game stream. As mentioned, GeForce Now is exclusively a game streaming service.
That means you have to log in twice to play a game, once for Nvidia Now, and again after launching into Steam, Epic, or whatever service the game resides on. I also noticed my display settings and other configuration details rarely carried over between sessions. You can do just three things in the client: view your account settings, add games to your library, and launch games.
Aside from one bizarre statement about negative latencyGoogle Stadia also avoids specific promises about latency. There is one competitor that does it better: Shadow.
The dark horse of cloud gaming offers a robust real-time monitoring tool with a real-time latency monitor.What is GeForce Now like?
The information it provides is difficult to understand without a cheat-sheet at the ready. For reference, each frame of a game running at a perfectly smooth 60 frames per second stays on-screen for The latency of GeForce Now translates to one to two frames of delay at 60 frames per second.
In those games, I found no reason to complain. I also spent a little time in Destiny 2 and Civilization VI. Again, latency was rarely a problem. Shadow, meanwhile, is on par with GeForce Now, reporting between 20 and 30 milliseconds on an Ethernet connection, and a few milliseconds beyond that over Wi-Fi. That decision is counterintuitive.
Nvidia, a leader in PC graphics, is closely linked to visual fidelity and high framerates.We are moving to a time when we will be doing most of all our computing in the Cloud. One of the most difficult things to do in the Cloud, however, is gaming because it is both resources intensive, and it requires very low latency.
It showcases state of the art regarding cloud computing for users, and it will help move us all into a cloud-based future. Most of us work off laptop computers that lack the performance, particularly the graphics performance of Triple-A games.
To get that performance historically, we are gaming desktop computer, a gaming laptop computer, or the willingness to try to play the game with all the graphics dialed back so it would run.
While you can upgrade most desktop computers with graphics to make them game cable laptops and all-in-one PCs are generally not upgradeable, and most of us use laptop computers these days. The experience is kind of like watching a major movie that was shot in IMAX on your cell phone. This advancement means we can get the laptop we want, which is lightweight, has good battery life, and has an affordable price AND use a cloud gaming service that provides the extra performance we need but only when we need it.
To get there, we needed hardware that was designed for cloud loading, a service that would provide access to it, and a low latency network so we could live with the result. With the 5G rollout, we are getting the low latency network we laptop users needed, and with GeForce NOW, we are getting a service that gives us the performance we need but only when we need it for gaming. Think of this service as a way to kick the tires. The current game library is 50 topflight games with more coming online every day.
Hundreds of games can be played with instant access and over 1, more are available with single-session installs.
With GeForce NOW a Billion Cheap PCs Can Now Taste Gaming Greatness, Too
Next on the list are Chromebooks, which are like mobile terminals, and with this back-end cloud power, a Chromebook could be turned into the closest thing we have in the general market to a terminal. I expect that by the end of this decade, we will all largely be computing in the Cloud and using increasingly thin and light hardware that uses 5G or Wi-Fi 6 to get the network performance we need for this to work. You can try it out for free and see if you can live on the Cloud today and get ready for our Cloud future tomorrow.
Designed by a drunk guy we met on the subway. February 5, Share on facebook. Share on twitter. Share on linkedin. Share on whatsapp.
Getting Around The Performance Problem Most of us work off laptop computers that lack the performance, particularly the graphics performance of Triple-A games. Author Rob Enderle. Search for more. Related Posts. Why Choose a Career in IT? M Rafiq. All rights reserved tgdaily. Excuse the typo, we are still in Beta.Please share your forum-specific feedback and bug reports in the Forum Feedback community.
Update avatar. Browse or drag an image. File must be atleast xpx and less than xpx. GeForce Forums. Discover Support Search Quit being a lurker! Join the community and customize your feed. Join Now or Login. Game-Ready Drivers. GeForce Experience. GeForce NOW.
Community Talk. Legacy Products. Trending topics. VenomVenin 5. Frame droping in Fortnite! RichardJones1 0. New PC crashing when playing games - help request. My display driver kinda crashes, and i get blackscreens under load. Total War : Warhammer 2. Virtual Reality advice needed.
AfjalKhan 0. Rhominas 0. World of warships update problem. Kimon11 0. World of Warships is updating too late everytime. Strange age police error when I want to log in to GFN. Killercheeetah 0.Nvidia announced on Tuesday that its GeForce Now game streaming service is out of beta and is available on full release for everyone.
The main gist of GeForce Now is that it lets you play PC games on a wide variety of devices, including desktops, laptops, mobile devices, Nvidia Shield streaming devices, and even Macs and low-power Chromebooks.
The games themselves run on computers in Nvidia's cloud, and a game's video is streamed over the internet, much like a Netflix video. It can easily be its own standalone service, or it can complement a PC gaming setup by bringing games to any device wherever there's a good internet connection.
All-in-all, GeForce now is geared for those entrenched in PC gaming platform rather than console gaming, but many gamers play on both platforms. If this idea sounds familiar, that's because numerous cloud game streaming services are beginning to emerge, like Google Stadia and Microsoft's Project Xcloudand these nascent services have the potential to make a big impact on the gaming industry and how people play video games.
Check out all the relevant details you need to know about GeForce Now, and the main ways it's already better than Google's Stadia:. For both GeForce Now memberships, users need to buy — or already own — the games they want to play. With that said, it's not difficult to achieve this. Microsoft's Project Xcloud game streaming app can also make the same claim.
Nvidia touts that it's an open platform, which is to say that you can access a wide variety of games stores, including Steam, Uplay, Epic Games Store, and Battle. By default, that means GeForce Now has hundreds more games than Stadia, which is its own ecosystem and has its own game store. Google truly has an uphill battle to fight as it creates an entirely new game store, whereas Nvidia works with established stores that already have millions of users.
This is a key differentiator from Google's Stadia, where you have to buy a game separately to play on Stadia, even if you own it on a different platform. And because Stadia is its own ecosystem, your progression in a game is only saved within Stadia.
Your game's progression in Stadia won't transfer to the same game on a different platform.
Still, GeForce Now doesn't fix the issue of owning both a gaming PC and a console, where you often have to buy games twice if you want to play them on each platform. And each game's progress is also exclusive to each platform. Like Stadia, you'll be able to play games on a wide variety of devices, including PCs, Macs, mobile devices, and the Nvidia Shield media streaming device for TVs. You could be playing a game on GeForce Now while playing against someone running a game locally on their PC, for example.
Certain games support a graphics effect called "ray tracing," which is enabled by Nvidia's ray tracing technology in its graphics cards. Ray tracing basically makes for more realistic lighting, shadows, and reflections in games.
Since a video game's video is streamed over the internet in a similar way that a Netflix video is streamed, there's going to be some kind of lag, or latency, compared to the experience of playing a game directly on a device itself.